Monday, 5 May 2014

Tolstoy on the Importance of Books and Literacy in Prisons

"When you are free you don't have such a painful desire to read as you have in prison. You can get any book at home, in the shops or from the internet. In prison books become the air. Your body needs air to breathe. No books – you cannot breathe. And if you cannot breathe there is no life."
- Belarusian journalist Iryna Khalip, who was detained for criticising her country's regime, now contributing to the campaign against banning books in UK prisons

Tolstoy's belief in education and learning for all
Leo Tolstoy, an author committed to education and
literacy for all, would certainly condemn the UK
restrictions on prisoners receiving books.
Over the last few months, countless artists, writers and readers have spoken out against 'book bans' in UK prisons. New rules, which came into force last November, now prevent prisoners from receiving parcels from outside, including books and magazine subscriptions, unless for 'exceptional circumstances'.

In an article by The Guardian, one prisoner, who was about to start a distance learning course, states: "A friend of mine has done all these courses and is fully qualified and was going to send me all his books but we can't have books sent in any more."

When thinking about this unfathomable decision by the British prison system, Resurrection by Leo Tolstoy can be seen as key reading.

It's perhaps not a surprise that Tolstoy believed firmly in the redemptive qualities of reading for prisoners, what with the school he set up on Yasnaya Polyana, his estate, in order to increase literacy among peasants, and the work he did to reform Russian education and literacy rates.

The protagonist of Resurrection, Nekhlyudov, a character keen to find redemption by helping others, is forbidden from giving textbooks to a political prisoner for the sake of furthering his education. In protest, his argument with the prison general goes as follows:

'He needs textbooks. He wants to study.'
'Don't you believe it.' The general paused. 'They're not for studying. This is trouble-making.'
'But surely they need something to pass the time in their awful situation,' said Nekhlyudov.
'They never stop complaining. [...] They have comforts here that are not usually available in prisons.'

The general goes on to say by way of an excuse,
'They are given books with a spiritual content, and old periodicals. We have a library of suitable books. But they don't read much. At first they show some sort of interest, but very soon you'll find new books with half the pages uncut, and old ones with the pages unturned. We once ran a test,' said the general with something distantly resembling a smile, 'by inserting slips of paper. They never got moved. [...] Anyway, they soon settle down. They start off by being a bit restless, but it's not long before they're putting on weight, and they end up quite placid,' said the general, totally unaware of the sinister significance of his words.


Tolstoy wasn't the only author aware of the importance of books in prisons. Think of the well-read Abbé Faria in The Count of Monte Cristo, one of the greatest mentors in literature, who writes his masterwork, the Treatise on the Prospects for a General Monarchy in Italy, while imprisoned.

Brooks from The Shawshank Redemption and his library
Brooks from The Shawshank Redemption: a character who reinforces the crucial role that books play in prisons.

On a similar note, think of the library in The Shawshank Redemption film (you may remember its mention of Alexandre Dumas); a space of learning, hope and friendship which blooms and expands as the film progresses. When Andy Dufrasne threatens to reveal the scams going on within the warden's office, it's interesting to consider what's at the centre of the warden's threat:

The library? Gone... sealed off, brick-by-brick. We'll have us a little book barbecue in the yard. They'll see the flames for miles. We'll dance around it like wild Injuns! You understand me? Catching my drift?... Or am I being obtuse?

Books have long been at the centre of the prison system, for reasons of entertainment, education and transformation. Anyone who has read a book and felt changed as a result can relate to this. Therefore, perhaps it could only be a lack of reading on behalf of the decision makers and prison boards that could lead to such a rule being put in place.

This quote by Tolstoy, written over a century ago in Resurrection, worryingly seems as relevant today as it did upon publication:

'Where's the sense in using prison for a man who has already become corrupted by idleness or bad example, and keeping him in conditions of guaranteed or enforced idleness, rubbing shoulders with other men even more corrupt than he is?'

Prisons are where we need books most, and preventing their distribution is a cruel prevention of basic human liberty. Here's to hoping the UK prison system can pause to read, think and reconsider.


Like more of the same? Subscribe to the Tolstoy Therapy Newsletter and receive a round-up of the week's articles every Sunday to enjoy with your coffee. Click here to subscribe.

10 comments:

Brian Joseph said...

This really seems like a bad decision. I was curious and I Googled the subject. It seems like an issue of over control. One is always tempted to suspect that it has to do with controlling ideas whenever books are banned. I am not really sure that is what is going on here but either way this makes little sense.

James Henderson said...

Your thoughtful remarks provide a steadfast defense of books for prisoners. Without books one important avenue and aid for redemption is missing from prisoners' lives. The reference to Abbe Faria was especially on point as Edmond Dantes' life was literally turned around (at least temporarily). Further, I am encouraged to reread Tolstoy's Ressurection to share insights like those you referenced.

Lee-Anne said...

When I was in university I worked in a little independent bookshop. We had a relationship with the librarian at the local maximum security prison, and I loved hearing her stories of prisoners who had been helped by books. She saw First Nations inmates who were introduced to their culture for the first time through the prison library, and inmates who were able to obtain degrees which transformed their lives. Banning books for punishment is like withholding medicine from a sick person to teach them a lesson.

And I think I need to see The Shawshank Redemption!

tolstoytherapy said...

Brian, it doesn't make any sense to me either. A lot of high-profile people are protesting the decision, so hopefully it will be overturned. It's certainly not something you'd except to happen in the modern world, that's for sure.

Marshein said...

What a great post! I can hardly believe they're banning books in UK prisons! How barbaric! Prisons are barbaric enough already. When I used to think about being imprisoned (had such worries as a teenager!) I figured reading books would get me through.


Anyhow, thank you for this post; it's informative and interesting.

tolstoytherapy said...

Thank you - I'm so glad you enjoyed reading it! Barbaric is definitely an appropriate word to use... in my mind books have always been so close to the idea of getting through imprisonment. I really hope the prison boards realise their error and make some changes.

tolstoytherapy said...

This is such a wonderful comment, Lee-Anne... thank you for sharing it!


Your experience sounds so interesting, and the stories you heard must have been so memorable. I'm a firm believer in the way that reading can transform our lives, and I completely agree with the metaphor you used of withdrawing medicine from a sick person. Let's hope the protest against this silly decision continues here in the UK!


And I think you'd enjoy The Shawshank Redemption :) Hope you're doing well!

MarcyS said...

I am now reading Resurrection thanks to you!

tolstoytherapy said...

Wonderful, Marcy! As one of Tolstoy's later works (his last, in fact), it's very heavy reading, but I really hope you enjoy the experience. My advice would be take it slowly and don't feel pressured to read it quickly (I certainly didn't, and even had breaks from it several times!)

tolstoytherapy said...

Dear James, thank you so much for your comment - I'm so glad you've found my blog!


I couldn't agree more with you on your wonderful second sentence. I'm also glad you like the links I've made to The Count of Monte Cristo... you've got me thinking about rereading it now!


It would be great to hear if you decide to reread Resurrection. It's such an interesting novel, particularly when set against Tolstoy's own life and changing philosophies.


Best wishes,
Lucy